Italy's Privacy Regulator Fines Meta 805 Million Euros Over Facebook Gallery Access
Meta

Italy's Privacy Regulator Fines Meta 805 Million Euros Over Facebook Gallery Access

Italy's data protection authority has issued an 805 million euro (about $887 million) penalty against Meta, ruling that the Facebook app reached into Android users' photo galleries without asking for specific permission or explaining clearly what it was doing.

The case centres on a Facebook feature that surfaces pictures and videos from a phone's camera roll as suggestions for new posts. According to a report by China Daily, the regulator estimates that roughly 20 million Android users in Italy were affected.

Meta has said it will challenge the ruling, setting up another legal contest between the company and European regulators over how personal data is collected and used.

How the Camera-Roll Feature Drew Scrutiny

The feature in question proposes images from a user's device gallery as starting points for Facebook posts. To function, it needs access to the photos and videos stored on the phone.

The Italian authority found that Facebook requested that access through one broad, app-wide permission. That request was preceded by a general notice that, in the regulator's assessment, did not make it clear to users that they were also agreeing to gallery-based suggestions.

As a result, the regulator concluded that Meta processed users' photographs, videos and related data without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing people about the practice.

What the Regulator Is Requiring

Beyond the fine, the authority has given Meta 60 days to change how the feature works. The company must switch it off by default and request permission for it separately from other app permissions.

Meta is also required to explain plainly what the feature does and how users can disable it. The aim is to ensure that people who enable gallery suggestions understand exactly what they are agreeing to.

Why the Penalty Was Set So High

In calculating the fine, the regulator pointed to the large number of people affected. It also noted that the conduct was still continuing for users who had not updated the app and for those who had already granted consent under the existing system.

The authority additionally cited what it described as a lack of cooperation from Meta during its investigation, a factor that weighed against the company in setting the amount.

The penalty ranks among the largest an Italian authority has imposed on a technology company. It surpasses the competition fine levied on Amazon in 2021, which was originally set at 1.1 billion euros and reduced to 752 million euros on appeal.

Meta Pushes Back and Plans an Appeal

Meta rejected the regulator's findings. A company spokesperson said Meta strongly disagrees with the assessment and objected to "the disproportionate level of the fine."

In a statement to the BBC, Meta described the tool as a simple way to help people share photos and videos on Facebook. The company said users must grant permission on their device before the feature can run and can revoke that permission at any time through their settings.

Although large by Italian standards, the penalty is modest relative to Meta's size. AFP estimated it at roughly 0.4 percent of the company's annual turnover, and Meta reported $201 billion in revenue for 2025.

The Italian decision follows a much larger penalty in the United States. Last month, authorities in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion over its business practices, after a judge ruled the company had misled state residents for more than a decade about how their data was used.

That was a record fine for Meta, which criticised it as a tax on freedom of expression.

What the Ruling Signals for App Makers and Users

The decision underlines a recurring point in European privacy enforcement: bundling several data uses under a single broad permission can fall short of the specific, informed consent regulators expect. Features that seem convenient to product teams may still require their own clear opt-in.

For startups and established developers alike, the case is a reminder to design permission flows that spell out each use of sensitive data such as personal photos. For users, the required changes should make it easier to see what Facebook can access and to turn gallery suggestions off. How Meta's appeal fares will indicate whether the regulator's approach holds.

Source: China Daily

Topics:

JeffkomStory Team

Editorial, JeffKom Story

The JeffKom Story newsroom covers startups, founders, funding and the technology shaping what’s next.

Keep reading

The Record Sues Surround Sound Media, Alleging Automated Copying of Local News
Media & Entertainment

The Record Sues Surround Sound Media, Alleging Automated Copying of Local News

More in Meta