Meta is facing one of the largest penalties an Italian regulator has ever issued to a technology company. The country's data protection authority has fined the Facebook parent €805m, roughly $887m, over the way its Android app reached into users' phone galleries.
The regulator found that Facebook accessed photos, videos and associated metadata belonging to Italian users without securing specific consent or giving them adequate information about what was happening, according to a report by The Guardian. Meta has said it will challenge the ruling.
The Feature at the Center of the Case
The penalty concerns Facebook's gallery suggestions tool, which has been available since 2023. While people scroll through the app, the feature surfaces images and videos stored on their phones and proposes them as material for new posts.
To work, the feature needs access to a device's photo gallery. The Italian authority took issue with how Facebook obtained that access on Android devices.
Why Regulators Said Consent Fell Short
According to the regulator, Facebook asked for gallery permission through a single authorization covering the whole app. That request came after a broad notice that talked about enabling other features.
In the authority's view, this setup left users unable to understand that by granting permission they were also allowing the app to pull suggestions from their personal photo collections.
Going forward, Meta must ask for consent through a separate, dedicated request tied specifically to the gallery feature. The company will also need to explain clearly that the feature involves access to a user's photos and show people how to switch it off.
How the Size of the Fine Was Set
The authority said it weighed the scale of the problem, noting that around 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. It also considered how long the infringement has lasted.
The regulator described the violation as ongoing for users who have not updated the app and for those who already gave consent under the old system. It further cited what it called a lack of cooperation from Meta during the investigation.
The resulting penalty equals roughly 0.4% of the group's annual turnover. Meta reported revenue of $201bn in 2025, with net profit of $60.5bn.
Meta Pushes Back
Meta has said it intends to appeal. A company spokesperson said Meta would contest both the regulator's findings and what it considers an excessive penalty, stating that "we strongly disagree" with the assessment.
Appeals can significantly change outcomes in Italy. In 2021, Amazon was hit with a fine of more than €1.1bn for breaching competition law, a sum later cut to €752m on appeal.
A Growing List of Legal Pressures
The Italian decision lands only weeks after another major ruling against the company in the United States. In late October, authorities in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25bn for misleading the state's residents over more than a decade about how their data was used.
That was a record fine for Meta, which criticized it by describing it as a tax on freedom of expression. Taken together, the two cases show regulators on both sides of the Atlantic scrutinizing how the company handles personal information.
What the Ruling Signals for Tech Companies
The case highlights a recurring issue in European privacy enforcement: bundled permissions. Regulators increasingly expect apps to request access feature by feature, rather than relying on a single broad approval that users may not fully understand.
For founders and product teams building consumer apps, the lesson is practical. Permission flows that explain exactly what data is used, for which feature, and how to turn it off are becoming a baseline expectation, and getting them wrong can prove costly as Meta's appeal moves forward.
Source: The Guardian





