A small nonprofit newsroom on Chicago's North Shore has taken a digital media rival to federal court, alleging that the competitor repeatedly reused its original journalism and photography without permission.
The Record Community News, which publishes The Record North Shore, filed a copyright infringement complaint against Surround Sound Media, the Chicago-based company that reportedly runs the website North Shore Weekly. The case was filed on Monday, Nov. 9, in U.S. District Court, according to a report by The Record North Shore.
The dispute highlights a growing tension in local media: how traditional reporting operations coexist with outlets that rely heavily on automated tools to produce community news at scale.
What the Complaint Alleges
According to the lawsuit, North Shore Weekly reproduced copyrighted material from The Record's website at least 22 times between June 18 and July 23. The complaint says the site published lightly reworded versions of The Record's articles and used its photographs instead of doing its own reporting.
The Record also claims that bylines, photo credits, captions and other copyright management information were removed or changed in the republished material. In total, the filing cites 18 examples involving text and nine involving photos, covering 27 works.
The newsroom is seeking a jury trial. It asks the court to bar Surround Sound from further copying or distributing its work, to require deletion of the allegedly copied content, and to award up to $25,000 per violation.
A Time Capsule Story at the Center
One example in the complaint involves a July 5, 2026, article from The Record about the Village of Winnetka opening a 50-year-old time capsule. The story and its lead photo were produced by Penelope Roewe, a former temporary employee, and both were registered with the U.S. Copyright Office, the complaint states.
Two days later, North Shore Weekly ran its own article on the same ceremony under the byline Ellie Nevel. Screenshots in the filing show it used the same lead photo, with the credit changed to read "Courtesy: The Record," and The Record alleges the text also copied protectable expression from Roewe's piece. The North Shore Weekly article no longer appears to be available online.
Automation and the Company's Response
The complaint alleges that Surround Sound uses automated software, including data-gathering pipelines and multi-step content-generation processes, to collect and publish local news across many communities. The company's website indicates it operates more than 170 local newsrooms nationwide.
A Surround Sound spokesperson provided a statement describing a hybrid model in which journalists set coverage priorities and make final publishing decisions, while AI tools monitor public records, flag developments and prepare drafts that journalists then verify and edit. Hilary Loewenstein, the company's head of strategic growth, declined to comment on the litigation.
The suit also names Robert Kellman, who reportedly founded and manages Surround Sound, alleging he personally directed and approved the republication of The Record's work.
Legal Basis and Competitive Harm
The Record's claims rest on two federal laws: the Copyright Act of 1976, which grants creators exclusive rights over original works, and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, which prohibits removing or altering author names and other copyright information.
The complaint argues the two outlets compete for the same local audience, and that the alleged copying pulls readers, advertising, sponsorships and donor support away from The Record.
Why a Small Newsroom Went to Court
Joe Coughlin, The Record's co-founder and editor-in-chief, said he first heard from North Shore residents in June 2026 that the newsroom's work seemed to be appearing on another site. He said the lawsuit is meant to protect the organization's work and to stand up for small publishers facing similar issues.
Coughlin described the alleged conduct as "a threat to the work itself, to the work of small publishers," and to readers who rely on credible information. He also noted that because The Record publishes roughly four original articles each weekday, registering every piece with the Copyright Office is not a practical use of its time or money.
What the Case Could Signal for Local Media
The outcome may help clarify how far automated and AI-assisted publishers can go when drawing on reporting produced by others, particularly when attribution is altered. For nonprofit and independent newsrooms, the case underscores both the value of their original work and the practical limits of protecting it.
For media founders building AI-driven content operations, it is a reminder that editorial oversight claims will likely be tested against how sourcing and credit actually appear on the page. The allegations have not been proven, and the case now moves forward in federal court.
Source: The Record North Shore





