A group of technology companies has made a final push to change Canada's lawful-access legislation before it clears Parliament, with two of the world's best-known secure messaging providers signalling they could leave the Canadian market rather than weaken encryption.
Representatives from Meta and Signal appeared before the Senate national security committee on Monday evening, alongside executives from two Canadian firms, virtual private network provider Tailscale and cybersecurity company Beauceron Security. All of them asked senators to amend Bill C-22, which has already passed its stages in the House of Commons, according to a report by The Globe and Mail.
What Bill C-22 Would Allow Ottawa to Do
The bill would give the federal government power to require electronic service providers, including messaging apps, to modify their systems so that police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service gain surveillance capabilities.
As currently drafted, it would let the Public Safety Minister issue ministerial orders to companies operating in Canada, and those orders would have to be kept secret by the firms receiving them.
Witnesses told senators that, in its present form, the legislation could make attacks by cybercriminals and hostile foreign governments more likely rather than less.
Meta and Signal Raise the Prospect of Withdrawal
Rachel Curran, head of public policy at Meta Canada, said the company, which owns the encrypted messaging service WhatsApp, would not comply with an order that required it to weaken encryption and would have to weigh all its options. She pointed to Apple's decision to withdraw affected services in Britain after receiving a technical assistance order it could not meet without undermining encryption on cloud backups.
Signal took a similarly firm line. Udbhav Tiwari, the company's vice-president of strategy and global affairs, told the committee that "Signal will never weaken its encryption or build surveillance into our systems." He said the company would choose leaving Canada over compromising its users' security.
Mr. Tiwari had previously said that government amendments made in the Commons did not resolve Signal's concerns, and that withdrawal from Canada remained a possibility.
Concerns Over Silent Participants and Metadata
Both Signal and Beauceron Security warned that the bill could be used to compel companies to let law enforcement quietly join encrypted conversations without the other participants knowing. David Shipley, chief executive of Beauceron Security, called for stronger protections for encryption and privacy to be written into the legislation.
Mr. Shipley also asked senators to strip out what he described as indiscriminate metadata retention requirements. Under the bill, companies could be required to keep customer metadata for up to six months. That would exclude e-mails, browsing history, social media activity and text messages, but could cover which phone numbers contacted each other and data capable of pinpointing a person's location.
Tailscale chief executive Avery Pennarun said even a single month of such data could reveal the shape of someone's social network, and the company's written submission warned that large stores of data firms would not normally collect could become a fresh target for hackers.
A Canadian Startup Weighs Moving Services Abroad
For Tailscale, the stakes are commercial as well as technical. The company provides end-to-end encrypted networking that lets devices connect directly to one another, and it serves more than 50,000 businesses worldwide, including many artificial intelligence companies. About 40 per cent of its more than 300 employees are based in Canada.
Mr. Pennarun said Tailscale has begun exploring options such as building partnerships overseas, selling or licensing some of its technology to foreign companies and dropping its Canadian branding to sidestep the legal and reputational issues the law could create.
He stressed that he does not oppose a lawful-access regime in principle, but said the bill needs fine tuning to avoid unintended consequences. He told senators it could damage the company's ability to sell its Canadian products internationally, describing it as potentially one of the developed world's most problematic privacy laws.
AI-Driven Threats Add Urgency
Several witnesses linked their concerns to the growing use of artificial intelligence in cyberattacks. Mr. Tiwari urged senators to require independent technical assessments to determine whether a ministerial order would compromise cybersecurity, arguing that AI tools capable of autonomously finding and exploiting deliberately built weaknesses make such checks essential.
Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told the committee that AI-enabled cyberattacks are spreading globally and that state actors and criminals are increasingly targeting governments, critical infrastructure and private networks.
What the Senate Review Means for Canada's Tech Sector
The Senate stage represents one of the last opportunities for changes before the bill becomes law, and the industry testimony frames a clear trade-off for lawmakers between expanded investigative powers and the security and competitiveness of Canadian digital services.
For founders building privacy or security products in Canada, the outcome could shape where they base infrastructure, how they brand themselves abroad and whether international customers trust software developed under Canadian jurisdiction. For users, it may determine whether widely used encrypted apps remain available in the country at all.
Source: The Globe and Mail





